খুঁজুন
, ,
সোমবার, ১৬ই নভেম্বর ২০২৬
English

St. Martin’s series · Special report

St. Martin’s counts every tourist, but not what its people lose

Fish are scarce and tourism is limited. Young people are leaving their studies and coming home, land has gone to outsiders, and fishermen fear the sea near the border. There is no official record of these losses, and not one island fisherman sits on the committee that controls tourism.

St. Martin’s counts every tourist, but not what its people lose
Amir Ali, 59, a fisherman from Purbapara on St. Martin’s, has gone to sea since he was 12 or 13. When there are no fish, there is no other work on the island, and the land has gone to outsiders, he says. Photo: Jasim Uddin
Shariful Rukon
১৫ নভেম্বর ২০২৬, ২৩:৩২

Abdur Rashid sent his son to Dhaka to study, from St. Martin’s to Northern University.

During the Covid pandemic, he could no longer pay for it. His son came back to the island.

“Even my own son was studying at Northern University. During Covid I couldn’t pay, so he came back too,” says Rashid. For nine years he has been president of the island’s boat owners’ association.

His son is not alone. “Many of those who used to study in Dhaka or Chattogram have now come back.” Why? “Parents can’t pay the costs. There are fewer fish in the sea.”

No one has a count of how many have come back.

Yet the island keeps another count with great care. This season, visitors to St. Martin’s need a travel pass with a QR code. No more than about 3,500 tourists a day, on average, may go, and each must pay a Tk 100 environmental conservation fee. Hotels have also been told to keep a register of which tourist stays where. Counting tourists is important for saving the corals and the island; there is no doubt about that. But there is no official record of what the island’s roughly 8,500 people are losing as the sea, the corals and tourism change: their education, their land, their safety at sea, and their voice in decisions about their own future.

Climate talks have a name for such losses: non-economic loss and damage. These are losses that cannot be measured in money. To win international recognition, there is one condition: the loss must be documented.

Banglar Patrika has tried to put together a record of these losses. It drew on interviews with the island’s fishermen, boat owners, business people and women, government documents obtained under the Right to Information Act, and published official data. This is what it found:

  • Education: Of about 4,000 school-age children on the island, 729 are in school. Young people who went away to study are coming back because their families cannot pay.
  • Livelihoods: In the past five years, the upazila fisheries office has allocated nothing for alternative livelihoods in Teknaf, which includes St. Martin’s. Fishermen say their farmland has gone to hotels and resorts owned by outsiders.
  • Safety: According to the BGB’s Teknaf battalion, 434 fishermen have been detained in Myanmar since 2025. Fishermen have also been taken from waters near St. Martin’s.
  • Voice: The committee set up to control unregulated tourism on the island includes the president of the hotel owners’ association, but no fisherman from the island and no one from the union parishad.
Abdur Rashid, president of the St. Martin’s boat owners’ association
Abdur Rashid, president of the St. Martin’s boat owners’ association. Many young people from the island, his son among them, have left their studies and come home because their families could not pay. Photo: Jasim Uddin

Leaving their studies, coming home

Young people on the island once had one path open to them. Because the Navy has a base on St. Martin’s, many were drawn to it. By Rashid’s count, three young men got Navy jobs every six months, six a year. “Now that this has stopped, interest in studying has also dropped.”

The damage starts even earlier, in school.

Of about 4,000 school-age children on the island, only 729 study at its four educational institutions. The island’s literacy rate is 15.13 percent, against 55 percent in Cox’s Bazar district. The dropout rate is 30 percent. The island’s only government primary school has two teachers for seven posts.

District Primary Education Officer Md. Shahin Mia explained why. Students get a stipend of Tk 200 to 250 a month, but carrying tourists’ bags for a single day earns Tk 500. So when the tourist season comes, children go to work. Some carry bags, some sell green coconuts, some go fishing.

Those who finish school find little work on the island. If they want to go back to the sea, there is little hope there either. In Rashid’s words: “There are no jobs, and there are no fish in the sea. All in all, there is distress everywhere on St. Martin’s now.”

How far have the fish declined?

“We used to get 1,000 to 1,500 hilsa in one trip. Now, even after going very far, we get only 10 to 15, or 20 hilsa,” says Rashid. He blames current nets (fine nylon nets) and big trawlers that “drag their nets along the seabed”, destroying everything from young fish to eggs.

Fishing days are also shrinking. Every year there are government fishing bans of 65 days and 22 days. “The ban comes exactly when it’s fishing time.” Then come the monsoon storms and winds, when, by Rashid’s count, “you can go to sea seven days a month at most.”

The island now has about 300 to 350 fishing boats. By Rashid’s count, about 1,500 fishermen work on them, and about 2,000 families depend on them.

Mohammad Salam has run a trawler for about 16 or 17 years. Five years ago, 10, 20 or 30 maunds of fish came up in a day. Now it is 10, 20 or 30 kg. What does he do when there are no fish?

“There’s nothing to do. There’s no work here. I just sit.”

Land gone to outsiders

If the sea gives nothing, what does the land offer?

Amir Ali, 59, lives in Purbapara in Ward 6. He has gone to sea since he was 12 or 13. Asked how he gets by when there are no fish, he answered in his local dialect. What he said means this: they live in deep hardship, eating less and making do with less, just getting by.

Going back to farming is almost impossible too. There was little land to begin with, and on top of that, “people from Dhaka, outsiders, came and bought the land, and it has become hotels, motels and resorts.” The old farmland “isn’t what it used to be.”

By his estimate, the island may have 12,000 people, and about 500 of them have work. The rest are jobless and sit idle in the market.

This is his estimate. The Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics’ 2022 census put the population of St. Martin’s Union at 8,492, although local representatives and residents say it is 10,000 to 11,000. No official figure could be found on how many people have work.

The tourism that became the island’s main economy is also mostly owned by outsiders. Toiyab Ullah, a descendant of the island’s original settlers who is involved with a resort, says: “The big resorts all belong to outsiders. The small cottages or buildings belong to locals.” Divide it into five parts, he says, and three belong to outsiders, two to locals.

Even those two parts mostly do not stay in local hands. “Even if they belong to locals, locals don’t run them. Many don’t have the links and lobbying; they can’t manage the tourists. So they lease them out.” What is left for the islanders is driving auto-rickshaws, running tea and snack stalls, and jobs at resorts.

This picture is not new. A 2010 Department of Environment publication itself stated that most owners of tourism businesses on the island were outsiders. As a result, tourism “contributes very little to the economic development of the island, while causing serious damage to natural resources.”

Sixteen years later, the structure is the same. Only one thing has changed: that tourism is now shut for most of the year.

Twelve months on four and a half months’ income

There are reasons to limit tourism. According to the draft master plan, before numbers were capped, up to 7,193 tourists stayed on the island in a single night, twice its carrying capacity.

Last season, daily visitors were capped at 2,000. Overnight stays were allowed only in December and January. From 1 February, the island was closed for nine months straight.

This season is longer. On 12 October, an inter-ministerial meeting chaired by Environment Minister Abdul Awal Mintoo decided that people may visit and stay on the island for four and a half months, from 1 November to 15 March, with no more than 3,500 a day on average. The fee could bring in about Tk 4.72 crore over the season.

The ministry has not explained why the limit rose from 2,000 to 3,500. The draft master plan itself proposes a maximum of 900 a day.

Even with a longer season, no tourists will go to the island for the other seven and a half months of the year. But costs run for all 12 months.

Speaking of last season, Shibli Azam Qureshi, president of the St. Martin’s Hotel-Resort Owners’ Association, says: “If we maintain for 12 months and do business for two, and capital is also employed for 12 months, we are suffering huge losses.” By his count, the island has about 200 hotels and resorts, employing about 2,000 people.

He claims the hotel sector alone has lost about Tk 100 crore, and more than Tk 1,000 crore once transport, ships, vans and rickshaws, shops and restaurants are added. This is the owners’ association’s estimate, not a verified figure. But two separate sources said more than 50 small resorts have closed.

Workers feel the blow too. Toiyab Ullah’s resort and restaurant had about 30 workers. Speaking of last season, he says: “I need fifteen people. After two months, I don’t need fifteen anymore. So someone who used to work six months will now work two. He thinks, two months won’t pay; I won’t go to St. Martin’s at all.”

Shibli Azam also claims that theft, robbery and mugging have started on the island in the off-season, which never happened before. No published police figures could be found to back this up.

On the last day of last season, 31 January, Foyezul Islam, acting chairman of the St. Martin’s Union Parishad, said: “Most people on the island depend on tourism. Everyone is frustrated because travel has suddenly been stopped for so long.” An auto-rickshaw driver said: “Now that tourists have stopped coming, we will again have to run our families in want and hunger.”

When tourism stops, people turn back to the sea. But the sea is no longer safe either.

Fear on the border sea

Amir Ali says that at this time of year, fish are plentiful in the sea east of the island. But fishermen are afraid to go there, because fishermen have been taken from there. Some were rescued and came back; the rest are still held in Myanmar.

Abul Kashem, who has gone to sea for about 38 years, says fishermen could once cast their nets on the Myanmar side of the sea too. Now, if they go there, armed men stop them and there is gunfire. “So we can’t go there anymore.” Shots also come on the way to Teknaf, he says. Abdur Rashid alleges that when boats pass through the Nakkhandia channel at the mouth of the Naf River, shots are fired from the Myanmar side, and the Arakan Army causes trouble.

The fishermen’s fear shows up in official figures too.

At a press conference in Teknaf on 19 August, Lt Col Hanifur Rahman Bhuiyan, commander of the BGB’s 2 Battalion, said that 434 fishermen in all had been detained in Myanmar since 1 January 2025. Of them, 348 had been brought back. At that time 86 were still held, 65 of them Bangladeshi.

Fishermen have been taken from near St. Martin’s too. On 27 November 2025, the Arakan Army took 12 Bangladeshi fishermen and two trawlers at gunpoint not far from the island. The news came from Md. Azim, president of the St. Martin’s Fishing Boat Owners’ Association.

Gunfire is not new either. On 5, 8 and 11 June 2024, boats heading for St. Martin’s were shot at from the Myanmar side at the Naikkhongdia point, where the Naf River meets the Bay of Bengal. After that, the Teknaf–St. Martin’s sea route was closed for about nine days.

Food and daily essentials then ran short on the island.

Empty pots in bad weather

Being cut off like this is not new for the islanders. Even without gunfire, the link with Teknaf breaks whenever the weather turns bad: by Rashid’s count, sometimes for a week, sometimes for 15 days.

In Abul Kashem’s words: “If the wind blows for seven or eight days, the people of the island can’t travel, and they go hungry.” Rashid suggests that dredging the Golachar section would let boats run 24 hours a day.

How this crisis reaches the home could be heard in the words of women. On 8 August, the day Minister of State for Environment Sheikh Faridul Islam visited the island, several women spoke to journalists.

Khorsheda Begum’s household depends on the money her husband makes selling fish. “When the season comes, we sell fish and get two or three thousand taka. We somehow get by on that. I have four children; we struggle along with them. I’ve educated one up to class nine, and another studies at a madrasa.”

Rashida Akter’s husband is ill, and she has four daughters at home. “We can pick up a few fish and eat; otherwise things are hard now. When we’re in trouble, we go to the ward member or the chairman. It’s not that they always give; sometimes they do, sometimes they don’t.”

None of the four women who spoke that day could name a single government programme. They rely on the season’s fish, the kindness of local representatives, and whatever someone leaves behind.

Women of St. Martin’s speaking to journalists
Women of St. Martin’s tell journalists about their hardship on the day the Minister of State for Environment visited the island, 8 August 2026. Photo: Courtesy of Jamuna TV

Sinking homes, salty water

The fear of losing their homes is also old for the islanders.

“The cyclones of 1991 and ’94 did extensive damage to St. Martin’s. That’s when the rocks were lowered,” Toiyab Ullah recalls. “In 1997, the whole of Deilpara went under water. The government gave fifty families shelter in a cluster village.”

He wrote the same in his own article in Prothom Alo on 30 July 2025: after the cyclones, two neighbourhoods, Uttarpara and Deilpara, disappeared, and in 1997 their residents were given homes in a cluster village under the Ashrayan project.

The erosion has not stopped. In Cyclone Mocha in 2023, several feet of coastal land in Deilpara and a few other neighbourhoods were lost to the sea.

In the first part of this series, Toiyab Ullah said: “We too now feel that we won’t be able to stay here in future. Even if we can, our children may not.”

Even the water under their feet is no longer safe.

“St. Martin’s is surrounded by sea, but its water used to be very fresh and drinkable,” says Professor Mohammad Shah Nawaz Chowdhury of the Institute of Marine Sciences at the University of Chittagong. With more people visiting, more groundwater is being pumped out, and salt water from around the island is seeping in. Waste left by tourists is also buried in the ground. “We are very afraid that the underground fresh water may become contaminated. If that is contaminated, the island’s prospects are alarming.”

The islanders have already felt salt water’s blow. In Cyclone Sitrang in 2022, seawater flowed in and turned tube wells and ponds in low-lying areas salty. Mariam Bibi of Dakshinpara said then: “We had a tube well at our house. After Sitrang, the water from that tube well became salty.” In the words of Mujibur Rahman, the union parishad chairman at the time: “There is a severe shortage of drinking water across a large part of the island.”

No official test results on the salinity of the island’s water have been published.

The island has no seat at the table

Schooling, land, sea, homes, water. So where are these losses discussed?

A document obtained under the Right to Information Act hints at the answer.

On 19 November 2024, the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change formed a committee “to control unregulated tourism on St. Martin’s Island”. Its conveners are the upazila nirbahi officers (UNOs) of Teknaf and Cox’s Bazar Sadar. Its members are representatives of the Ministry of Civil Aviation and Tourism or the Tourism Board, the BIWTA, the Coast Guard and the Tourist Police. The member secretary is the deputy director of the Department of Environment in Cox’s Bazar.

The committee’s tasks: checking travel passes, stopping banned plastic, keeping a register of which hotel each tourist stays in, and putting up billboards.

Seven days later, at a meeting on 26 November, five more people were added to the committee: the officer-in-charge of Cox’s Bazar Sadar Model Police Station, the presidents of the tourism business groups TOAC and JOAB, the president of the Cox’s Bazar Press Club, and the president of the St. Martin’s hotel owners’ association.

The tourism business got a seat. The island’s fishermen, boat owners, union parishad and scientists did not.

The meeting’s decisions were also about which jetty the ships would leave from, travel passes, plastic and billboards. The minutes record no discussion of the islanders’ income or alternative livelihoods.

Minutes of the St. Martin’s tourism control committee meeting
Part of the minutes (in Bangla) of the 26 November 2024 meeting of the committee to control unregulated tourism on St. Martin’s, listing the members who were added. Source: Office of the Deputy Commissioner, Cox’s Bazar (obtained under the Right to Information Act)

The islanders’ experience is the same. No one talked to them before the decisions to control tourism were made, says Toiyab Ullah. The islanders went to Dhaka on their own and met the then environment adviser, Syeda Rizwana Hasan. “She said that around February she would talk with the people of St. Martin’s about the master planning. She never came, and never talked.”

His question goes back further. The island was declared an Ecologically Critical Area in 1999. Twenty-seven years later, there is still no policy on building homes. “You can’t build buildings, fine. But at least there has to be permission to build a hut. A hundred feet, two hundred feet from the beach, with trees all around: shouldn’t there be a rule like that? They haven’t given one.”

(Toiyab Ullah is himself involved with a resort; his position on tourism is tied to a business interest. At the same time, he is a descendant of the island’s original settlers and a long-time rights activist.)

What gets counted, and what does not

The state keeps some counts very precisely. As the first part of this series showed, last fiscal year the VGF (Vulnerable Group Feeding) allocation for St. Martin’s Union was recorded to five decimal places: 101.99075 tonnes, for 2,392 beneficiaries.

The count for alternative livelihoods needed no decimals. The office of the Teknaf Upazila Senior Fisheries Officer stated in writing: “No allocation has been made from this office’s revenue budget or projects over the past 5 years for the implementation of alternative livelihood programmes for Teknaf Upazila (including St. Martin’s).” Asked about compensation or alternative livelihoods, the Cox’s Bazar district administration and the office of the Teknaf UNO both said they held no information on this.

Scientists also say that saving the island means keeping its people on board. “Local people are not against the environment,” Professor Shah Nawaz Chowdhury said in the first part of this series. “They want to protect it. But they want to be sure of two meals a day.” That security must come through alternative livelihoods that do not harm the environment.

For two months, questions for this series were sent to the environment minister, the minister of state and the environment secretary by email, WhatsApp and phone. They did not reply.

This season, every tourist who goes to the island will be counted through travel passes and QR codes, up to 3,500 a day on average.

How many young people, like Rashid’s son who came back from Northern University, have left their studies and returned to the island? No one has counted.

Read more: St. Martin’s series, Part 1: Four killers stalk St. Martin’s corals; no one measures three of them

Read more: St. Martin’s series, Part 2: A plan to protect a coral reef that does not exist

Read more: As anchors rise, St. Martin’s corals break


This story was produced as part of the Earth Journalism Network (EJN) fellowship on non-economic loss and damage (NELD).

আপনার মতামত লিখুন

আপনার ইমেইল ঠিকানা প্রকাশ করা হবে না। প্রথমবার মন্তব্য করলে তা মন্তব্য নীতি অনুযায়ী যাচাইয়ের পর প্রকাশিত হয়।

English থেকে আরও